Robbie Banfitch is a wholly unique figure in the world of found-footage horror, creating original (and sometimes divisive) films that bring fresh perspectives on a subgenre that too often leans on the same tired tropes. Tinsman Road follows up on Banfitch’s 2022 film The Outwaters, and takes a similarly big swing; this time, however, the gambit is emotional, as the multi-hyphenate filmmaker (Banfitch wrote, edited, produced, shot, and recorded sound for the film as well as directing and starring in it) returns to his real childhood home for a horror-drama hybrid that scares viewers while also plunging them into a deep well of sadness. Bring tissues.